2002-303128
, DOC # ~O2-0303128
7594 APR 11. 2002 12:41. PM
Recording Requested By: ')
"\ ~ ) OFFICIAl RECORDS
City Engineer ) SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER'S OFFICE
GREGORY J. SMITH, COUNTY RECORDER
) FEES: 26.00
When Recorded Mail to: 1111111111111111111111111111111111111 11111 11111 IIIIIIIIII 1111111111111
City Clerk
City ofEncinitas 2002.0303128
505 South Vulcan Avenue )
Encinitas, CA 92024 ) SPACE ABOVE FORRECORDEæS USE ONLY
fg 1IP!
5~Y~ PRIVATE ROAD
1f :f MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT
¡vfi\ FOR TPM 99-162
Assessor's Parcel No. 264-091-59 Project No.: TPM 99-162
THIS AGREEMENT for the maintenance and repair of that certain private road easement, the
legal description made a part hereof, is entered into by STEVEN ROBERT SAPPER, TRUSTEE
OF THE STEVEN ROBERT SAPPER GIFT TRUST DATED JULY 19, 1990, NON-EXEMPT
TRUST "A" AS TO AN UNDIVIDED ONE PERCENT (1%) INTEREST; MICHAEL
WILLIAM SAPPER, TRUSTEE OF THE MICHAEL WILLIAM SAPPER GIFT TRUST
DATED JULY 19,1990, NON-EXEMPT TRUST "A", AS TO AN UNDIVIDED ONE
PERCENT (1%) INTEREST; AND DAVID EUGENE SAPPER, TRUSTEE OF THE DAVID
EUGENE SAPPER GIFT TRUST DATED JULY 19, 1990, NON-EXEMPT TRUST "A", AS
TO AN UNDIVIDED ONE PERCENT (1%) INTEREST AND SAPPER FAMILY
PARTNERS, L.P" A CALIFORNIA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, AS TO A 97% INTEREST
(hereinafter referred to as "Developer") for the benefit of future subdivision lot owners who will
use the private road easement (hereinafter referred to as "lot owners", which shall include the
Developer to the extent the Developer retains any ownership interest in any lot or lots).
WHEREAS, this Agreement is required as a condition of approval by the City of Encinitas
of a subdivision project as defined in Section 21065 of the Public Resources code and pursuant
to City of Encinitas Municipal Code Section 24.16.060 and Section 24,29.040; and
WHEREAS, Developer is the owner of certain real property being subdivided and developed as
TPM 99-162 that will use and enjoy the benefit of said road easement. A
complete legal description of the real property as described in Exhibit "A"
attached hereto and made a part hereof:
Said real property is hereinafter referred to as the "property"; and
,. ' .
7595
WHEREAS, it is the desire of the Developer that said private road be maintained in a safe
and usable condition by the lot owners; and
WHEREAS, it is the desire of the Developer to establish a method for the maintenance and
repair of said private road easement and for the apportionment of the expense of such
maintenance and repair among existing and future lot owners; and
WHEREAS, it is the intention of the Developer that this Agreement constitute a covenant
running with the land, binding upon each successive lot owner of all or any portion of the
property, NOW THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY AGREED AS FOLLOWS:
1. The property is benefited by this Agreement, and present and successive lot
owners of all or any portion of the property are expressly bound hereby for the benefit of the
land.
2. The cost and expense of maintaining the private road easement shall be divided
equally among the subdivided parcels created in the subdivision and paid by the lot owner of the
heirs, assigns and successors in interest or each such owner.
3. In the event any of the herein described parcels of land are subdivided further, the
lot owners, heirs, assigns and successors in interest of each such newly created parcel shall be
liable under this Agreement for their then pro rata share of expenses and such pro rata shares of
expenses shall be computed to reflect such newly created parcels,
4. The repairs and maintenance to be performed under this Agreement shall be
limited to the following unless the consent for additional work is agreed to by a majority vote of
the lot owners owning 100% of the number of parcels, including subdivisions thereof as
described in Paragraph 3 above: reasonable and normal road improvement and maintenance
work to adequately maintain said private road easement to permit all-weather access and
conveyance of storm flows. Repairs and maintenance under this Agreement shall include, but is
not limited to, filling of chuckholes, repairing cracks, repairing and resurfacing of roadbeds,
repairing and maintaining drainage structures, removing debris, maintaining signs, markers,
striping and lighting, if any, and other work reasonably necessary and proper to repair and
preserve the easement for all-weather road purposes.
5, If there is a covenant, agreement, or other obligation imposed as a condition of
subdivision approval to make private road improvements to the private road easement, the
obligation to repair and maintain the private road easement as herein set forth shall commence
when the private road improvements have been completed and approved by the City.
6. Any extraordinary repair required to correct damage to said road easement that
results ÍÌ'om action taken or contracted for by lot owners or their successors in interest shall be
paid for by the party taking action or party contracting for work which caused the necessity for
, .
7596
the extraordinary repair. The repair shall be such as to restore the road easement to the condition
existing prior to said damage,
7. It is agreed that Developer is initially the agent to contract and oversee and do all
acts necessary to accomplish the repairs and maintenance required and/or authorized under this
Agreement. Developer further agrees that the agent may at any time be replaced at the direction
of a majority of the lot owners. Repair and maintenance work on the private road easement shall
be commenced when a majority of the lot owners agree in writing that such work is needed. The
agent shall obtain three bids from licensed contractors and shall accept the lowest of said three
bids and shall then initiate the work. The agent shall be paid for all costs incurred including a
reasonable compensation for the agent's services, and such costs shall be added to and paid as a
part of the repair and maintenance costs; provided, however, that compensation for the agent's
services shall in no event exceed an amount equivalent to 10% of the actual cost of repairs and
maintenance performed. In performing his duties, the agent, as he anticipates the need for funds,
shall notify the parties and each party shall within forty-five (45) days pay the agent, who shall
maintain a trustee account and also maintain accurate accounting records which are to be
available for inspection by any party or authorized agent upon reasonable request. All such
records shall be retained by the agent for a period of five years.
8. Should any lot owner fail to pay the pro rata share of costs and expenses as
provided in this Agreement, then the agent or any lot owner or owners shall be entitled without
further notice to institute legal action for the collection of funds advanced on behalf of such lot
owner in accordance with the provisions of California Civil Code Section 845, and shall be
entitled to recover in such action in addition to the funds advanced, interest thereon at the current
prime rate of interest, until paid, all costs and disbursements of such action, including such sum
or sums as the Court may fix as and for a reasonable attorneys fees.
9. Any liability of the lot owners for personal injury to the agent hereunder, or to any
worker employed to make repairs or provide maintenance under this Agreement, or to third
persons, as well as any liability of the lot owners for damage to the property of agent, or any such
worker, or of any third persons, as a result of or arising out of repairs and maintenance under this
Agreement, shall be borne, as between the lot owners in the same percentages as they bear the
costs and expenses of such repairs and maintenance. Each lot owner shall be responsible for and
maintain his own insurance, if any, By this Agreement, the Developer does not intend to provide
for the sharing of liability with respect to personal injury or property damage other than that
attributable to the repairs and maintenance undertaken under this Agreement. Each of the lot
owners agrees to indemnify the others from any and all liability for injury to himself or damage
to his property when such injury or damage results from, arises out of, or is attributable to any
maintenance or repairs undertaken pursuant to this Agreement.
10. Lot owners shall jointly and severally defend and indemnify and hold harmless
City, City's engineer and its consultants and each of its officials, directors, officers, agents and
employees from and against all liability, claims, damages, losses, expenses, personal injury and
other costs, including costs of defense and attorney's fees, to the agent hereunder or to any lot
, .
7597
owner, any contractor, any subcontractor, any user of the road easement, or to any other third
persons arising out of or in any way related to the use of, repair or maintenance of, or the failure
to repair or maintain the private road easement.
Nothing in the Agreement, the specifications or other contract documents or City's
approval of the plans and specifications or inspection of the work is intended to include a review,
inspection acknowledgement of a responsibility for any such matter, and City, City's engineer
and its consultants, and each of its officials, directors, officers, employees and agents, shall have
no responsibility or liability therefore.
11. The foregoing covenants shall run with the land and shall be deemed to be for the
benefit of the land of each of the lot owners and each and every person who shall at anytime own
all or any portion of the property referred to herein.
12. It is understood and agreed that the covenants herein contained shall be binding
on the heirs, executors, administrators, successors, and assignees of each of the lot owners.
13. It is the purpose of the signatories hereto that this instrument be recorded to the
end and intent that the obligation hereby created shall be and constitute a covenant running with
the land and any subsequent purchaser of all or any portion thereof, by acceptance of delivery of
a deed and/or conveyance regardless of form, shall be deemed to have consented to and become
bound by these presents, including without limitation, the right of any person entitled to enforce
the terms of this Agreement to institute legal action as provided in Paragraph 8 hereof, such
remedy to be cumulative and in addition to other remedies provided in this Agreement and to all
other remedies at law or in equity.
14. The terms of this Agreement may be amended in writing upon majority approval
of the lot owners and consent of the City.
15, This Agreement shall be governed by the laws of the State of California. In the
event that any of the provisions of this Agreement are held to be unenforceable or invalid by any
court of competent jurisdiction, the validity, and enforceability of the remaining provisions shall
not be affected thereby.
16. If the Property constitutes a "Common Interest Development" as defined in
California Civil Code Section 1351(c) which will include membership in or ownership of an
"Association" as derIDed in California Civil Code Section 1351(a), anything in this Agreement to
the contrary notwithstanding, the following provisions shall apply at and during such time as (i)
the Property is encumbered by a "Declaration" (as defined in California Civil Code Section
1351(h), and (ii) the Common Area of the property (including the private road easement) is
managed and controlled by an Association:
(a) The Association, through its Board of Directors, shall repair and maintain the
private road easement and shall be deemed the "agent" as referred to in Paragraph 7 above. The
Association, which shall not be replaced except by amendment to the Declaration, shall receive
, . 7598
no compensation for performing such duties. The costs of such maintenance and repair shall be
assessed against each owner and his subdivision interest in the Property pursuant to the
Declaration, The assessments shall be deposited in the Association's corporate account
(b) The provisions in the Declaration which provide for assessment liens in favor of
the Association and enforcement thereof shall supersede Paragraph 8 of the Agreement in its
entirety. No individual owners shall have the right to alter, maintain or repair any of the
Common Area (as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351(b) in the Property except as
may be allowed by the Declaration.
(c) This Agreement shall not be interpreted in any manner which reduces or limits the
Association's rights and duties pursuant to its Bylaws and Declaration.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement
Developer:
,(,.,1Iv+- date
l.r(t'O-
/2~ 'L
.:u~~~~
(print name:) 0"'\1 '-~ IV¡\\,~-.I... date
~ ,~
~ - /-i!If.p'l--
(Print name:) }t",,-I+<-¡"""+ date
E.I/. S"?/'tfý 5""..,.
Signature of DEVELOPERS must be notarized, Attach the appropriate acknowledgement
, .
7599
State of California
County of San Diego
On 01/28/02 before me, H. J. Haro
(OATE) (NAMElTlTLE OF OFFICER.i.,. "JANE 000, NOTARY PUBLIC")
personally appeared Steven Robert Sapper,
(NAME(S) OF SIGNER(S»
Michael William Sapper, David Eu2ene Sapper The information requested below
and Eu2ene Herbert Sapper and in this column is Optional.
ŒJ personally known to me - OR - D proved to me on the Recording of this document is not
basis of satisfactory required by law and is also
evidence to be the optional. It could, however,
person(s) whose name(s) prevent fraudulent attuchment of
is/are subscribed to the this certificate to any unauthorized
within instrument and document.
acknowledged to me that
he/she/they executed the
same III his/her/their
authorized capacity(ies),
and that by his/her/their
signature( s) on the Priyate Road Maintenance Agreement
instrument the person(s), for TPM 99.162
or entity upon behalf
of which the person(s) Number of Pages: 6
acted, executed the Date of Document: 01/28/02
instrument. Other Signer(s) of Document:
ri" H. J. HARO ¡
;; if:"", , ~OMM.. # 1207962 ~
~ ;~ ARY PUBLIC ' CALIFORNIA ~
~ .. > .. SAN DIEGO COUNTY -
! "'...,Ö", ..:~m,m..Expir.SJan..14, ~OO!J
CAPACITY CLAlMED BY SIGNER(S) CAPACITY CLAfMED BY SIGNER(S)
0 INDlYJDUAL(S) 0 INDIVIDUAL(S)
0 CORPORATE OFFiCER(S) 0 CORPORATE OFFfCER(S)
TI""", Tm~S)
RlGHT THUMBPRINT 0 PARTNER(S) 0 LIMITED RlGHT THUMBPRINT 0 PARTNER(S) 0 LIMITED
0 0 GENERAL (Optional) 0 GENERAL
0 ATTORNEY IN FACT D 0 ATTORNEY IN FACT
0 TRUSTEE(S) I!J TRUSTEE(S)
D GUARDIAN/CONSERVATOR D GUARDIAN/CONSERVATOR
DOrnER D OTHER
SIGNER IS REPRESENTING, SIGNER IS REPRESENTING,
(N'm"fP,nooM" E""Yliœ) (N,m'ofPmooM"E""'YIiœ)
GIItT'o"'.ndS.ppœ
F.mIIyP.rtn,n,LP.
, .
7600
ATTACHMENT "A" í
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
THE LAND REFERRED TO HEREIN IS SITIJATED IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY
OF SAN DIEGO, AND IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
THAT PORTION OF LOT 18 OF THE SUBDMSION OF RANCHO LAS ENClNlTAS, IN TIlE
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, ACCORDING TO MAP THEREOF NO. 848,
FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF SAN DIEGO COQNTY, JUNE 27, 1898,
AND OF A PORTION OF VACATED "J" STREET ADJACENT TO SAID LOT 18, DESCRIBED AS
FOLLOWS: .
COMMENCING AT TIlE INTERSECTION OF THE EASTERLY PROLONGATION OF 1HE CENTER
LINE OF 12TIl STREET WITII THE CENTER LINE OF "J" STREET AS SHOWN ON COLONY OF
OLIVENHAIN, ACCORDING TO MAP TIIEREOF NO, 326, FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE
COUNTY RECORDER OF SAN DIEGO COUNTY, JULY 8,1885; THENCE ALONG TIlE CENTER
LINE OF SAID "J" STREET NORTII J4018'00" EAST, 990,00 FEET TO A POINT HEREIN
DESIGNATED AS POINT "A"; THENCE CONTINUING ALONG SAID CENTER LINE OF "J"
STREET, NORTIl 14°18'00" EAST, 591.70.FEET TO THE CENTER LINE OF 14TIl STREET AS
SHOWN ON SAID MAP NO. 316; THENCE ALONG THE WESTERLY PROLONGATION OF THE
CENTER LINE OF SAID 14TIl STREET, NORTIl 74°38'00" WEST TO A LINE WInCH IS PARALLEL
WITH AND 60.00 FEET WESTERLY OF AND MEASURED AT RIGHT ANGLES TO 1HE CENTER
LINE OF SAID "J" STREET; TIlENCE CONTINUING NORTH 74°38'00" WEST, 527.30 FEET TO THE
MOST WESTERLY LINE OF LAND DESCRIBED IN DEED TO HORACE G. PHILLIPS, ET UX,
RECORDED JANUARY 16, 1958 IN BOOK 6910, PAGE 17 OF OFFICIAL RECORDS; TIlENCE
ALONG SAID WESTERLY LINE sourn 14°18'00" WEST, 455.00 FEET; THENCE NORTIl 83°31'50"
EAST, 225,00, fEET TO THE TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING; TIlENCE CONTINUING NORTIl
83°31'50" E~, 403.11 FEET TO THE CENTER LINE OF SAID "J" STREET; TIlENCEALONG SAID
CENTER L ,SOUTIl 14°18'00" WEST, 360.23 FEET TO SAID POINT "A"; TIlENCE NORTIl
74°52'00" WEST, 295.91 FEET TO A LINE WHICH BEARS SOUTII 06°28'10" EAST FROM TIlE
TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING; TIlENCE NORTIl 06°28'10" WEST, 228.53 FEET TO TIlE TRUE
POINT OF BEGINNING.
COV99-162